ESPN’s Kirk Herbstreit sharply criticized Ohio State’s football schedule during Saturday’s broadcast, suggesting the Buckeyes’ 2024 season lacks competitive depth outside their marquee matchup against Texas.
“You look at who they’ve faced aside from Texas, and it’s hard to call that a strong schedule,” Herbstreit said, emphasizing the need for tougher nonconference challenges.
Herbstreit’s remarks came during an analysis of playoff contenders, where he noted that Ohio State’s performance might be misleading due to a relatively soft lineup of opponents. Several analysts agreed that the Buckeyes’ schedule could affect their playoff positioning if other Power Five teams post stronger resumes.
The comments drew mixed reactions from fans, with some defending Ohio State’s consistent success in the Big Ten while others admitted the lack of top-ranked opponents outside Texas could undermine their national standing.
“Winning in the Big Ten still counts,” one Big Ten analyst responded, “but when your toughest challenge was Texas back in September, that’s not ideal for playoff evaluation.”
Herbstreit’s critique reopens the long-standing debate about strength-of-schedule metrics in college football, particularly as expanded playoffs heighten the importance of head-to-head quality wins.
Author summary: Kirk Herbstreit accused Ohio State of crafting an easy schedule outside Texas, reigniting debate about the fairness and impact of weak schedules in playoff contention.