How accurate is Death by Lightning? Exploring facts vs fiction in the latest Netflix drama

How Accurate Is Death by Lightning?

Death by Lightning begins by posing a straightforward question: “Who is Charles Guiteau?” This inquiry sets the tone for Netflix’s latest historical mini-series, blending political thriller and tragedy with a deep focus on past realities.

The series raises a natural curiosity about how much of its story aligns with actual events in American history. The answer is that much of it does. Although some creative liberties are taken to enhance engagement, Death by Lightning remains largely faithful to the true account of President James Garfield’s ascent and sudden downfall.

However, a few imaginative details and altered timelines make this historical narrative feel almost too dramatic at times.

Portrayal of James Garfield

The mini-series presents James Garfield, played by Michael Shannon, as a modest man who never aspired to be president.

"The show starts off with him literally building a table as if it were to remind us that this guy’s hands were made for work and not politics."

This depiction is accurate. Garfield was indeed more content on his Ohio farm than in the political sphere of Washington.

Summary

Death by Lightning skillfully balances historical truth with narrative drama, portraying Garfield’s life and assassination with notable accuracy while adding cinematic elements for storytelling.

Soap Central — 2025-11-07