Worry-O-Meter for the Toronto Maple Leafs
If you're a Toronto Maple Leafs fan, you probably know that worrying comes with the territory. Years of hopes, heartbreaks, and endless debate have made following this team a constant emotional ride.
Many thought the Mitch Marner saga marked the end of one era and the start of another. Without Marner, the Leafs had a chance to redefine themselves with less pressure and more freedom. That plan depended on a strong beginning to the first Marner-less season, but things haven’t gone as hoped.
Early Struggles
Toronto is sitting at 5-5-1 after 11 games in the 2025–26 season—a record that reflects inconsistency more than promise. Although Matthew Knies has shown growth and delivered some solid performances, there have been more disappointments than successes.
- The power play currently ranks among the bottom five in the NHL.
- Auston Matthews’ production is down by his usual standards.
- Goaltending has been average at best, offering little stability.
It’s still early in the season, but these trends raise legitimate questions about the team’s direction and readiness to adapt.
Looking Ahead
The key question remains: should fans panic or stay patient? It may be too soon to sound the alarm after just 11 games, but the team needs to find consistency fast if it hopes to quiet critics and move past its recent turmoil.
“Should you worry about the Leafs yet, or should you sit back and enjoy the Toronto Blue Jays while the hockey team across the way figures it out?”
Author’s Summary
The Maple Leafs’ shaky 5-5-1 start raises anxiety among fans seeking stability after the Marner departure, but early-season struggles may still be reversible with focused adjustments.